Comfort Colors Pick Your Poison Tee, Witchy Halloween Shirt, Spooky Season Gift for Her

Five bottles laid out like a witch's bar cart: a jar of deadly nightshade in bloom, a corked flask with a snake curled inside, a small blue vial marked drink me, a faceted pink bottle, and a green-glazed apple with a skull staring out of it. Pick Your Poison arches over the shelf in dripping mint letters inside a curling art-nouveau frame, bats drifting past the corners. The blank is a Comfort Colors 1717 in 6.1 oz garment-dyed cotton, unisex and boxy through the body. Comfort Colors runs roomy, so size down one if you want it closer to the body, or keep your size for the drape in the photo. Wear it on a late-October bar crawl, to a costume-optional party where you would rather stay in your own clothes, and through the grey weeks after the decorations come down. It is an apothecary shelf, not a horror poster - no gore anywhere on it. Order by October 18 for delivery before Halloween. Send it to the friend who always orders the strangest thing on the cocktail menu.

Comfort Colors 1717 · garment measurements (inches). Width is armpit to armpit laid flat, length is shoulder to hem — lay a shirt you already like on a table and compare. Fit runs relaxed: size down one for a closer cut. Full size guide

Free U.S. shipping on orders over $75.00. Standard shipping is $6.99 below that, dispatched in 1-2 business days with 3-6 days in transit.

Full shipping policy →

Returns and exchanges are accepted within 30 days of delivery, with no restocking fee.

Full return policy →